Alan Thornett

Alan Thornett: 15 June 1937 – 9 October 2026

Day and night efforts bring Cowley's bell-to-bell betrayal!

Socialist Organiser no. 129, Industrial Special supplement, 28 April 1983, pp. 1–2 of the supplement (scan pp. 7–8)

'The problem was not resolve of the workers, but manoeuvres at the top'

Transcribed by hand from the printed page.

THE 4½ week Cowley strike, like the London Docks strike, the South Yorkshire steel strike and the recent strikes at Ford and in the South Wales coalfield, reflected the willingness and ability of the working class to fight back against the Tory government.

The betrayal of this strike therefore has implications, not just in Cowley, or even BL, but for the working class as a whole. In some ways the implications outside Cowley are more negative than within the plant.

The record of the working class in successive strikes since Thatcher came to power in May 1979 has been a willingness to fight. The record of the trade union leaders has been one of opposition to an industrial challenge to the Tories.

Politics

These are the politics which lay behind the sell-out at Cowley.

Cowley workers are in a powerful strategic position. Their strike instantly affects not only four models in BLs highest-investment plant, but a section of the engineering industry as well. Compare the publicity and the attention of top union leaders for the Cowley strike with London Docks, where workers have been out two weeks longer.

If the trade union leaders wanted to fight, Cowley was a perfect situation to do so. The sell-out of the strike under these conditions makes its effects on the working class more damaging. Many workers will think that if a victory was not possible at Cowley, where is it possible?

If nothing else can be said for Moss Evans, Terry Duffy, Ken Cure and Grenville Hawley in this issue, their determination and singlemindedness in getting the Cowley Assembly Plant workers back to work on the company's terms should be recognised.

From the time Moss Evans arrived for the talks last Thursday at a plush hotel near Gatwick in the same car as Austin Rover chairman Harold Musgrove, they have worked unstintingly.

Variant

At that meeting, management repeated a slight variant of their original terms: Audited Plant Status (APS) to be introduced by May 16, 1983 bell to bell running to be introduced by May 30, a four person inquiry into labour relations in the plant.

Out of this meeting came "trade union" proposals which were almost identical to management terms, to be put to a mass meeting the following day, Friday: "Audited Plant Status will only be introduced in Cowley Assembly from Monday May 16 1983, given cooperation by the workforce in the productivity improvement measures necessary to qualify for APS which includes the 39 hour week, this to be brought about by agreement of the trade unions or by a ballot of the workforce."

Ballot

In other words they were saying accept APS (they seem incapable of grasping that the workforce doesn't want it), and accept bell to bell running.

The only problem, they were saying, was that the company wanted to force these things in, and that was undemocratic. Incredibly, they were saying that the way to avoid such an imposition was voluntarily to accept BL's terms.

The key sentence is "this [APS and bell to bell running] to be brought about by agreement of the trade unions or ballot . . ."

This gave them two options – get BL to agree to a ballot, or simply agree to the terms themselves.

The shop stewards committee, meeting immediately before Friday's mass meeting, rejected both management and trade union proposals. Instead they passed a resolution calling on the workers to reject BL's terms, to continue the strike and to meet again in a week's time.

The mass meeting was very big, with all the 5,000 strikers attending. The mood was not quite as strong as before. The waverings at national level, and the hardships workers were now facing, were having some effect.

The vote however, was a solid 3-1 in favour of the shop stewards resolution. The problem of the strike was not the resolve of the workers but the manoeuvrings at the top.

After the vote, which most workers saw as the end of the meeting, Buckle announced that there was to be a second vote on the trade union proposals – that BL's terms were OK providing they were voluntarily accepted and not imposed.

There was complete confusion. Hundreds of workers were streaming out of the meeting as Buckle tried to explain the reason for the second vote.

The trade union proposals were then carried with maybe 100 votes in favour and 50 against.

That same evening Evans and Duffy acted on that second vote and met BL management again, this time in the Holiday Inn near Heathrow.

Final

At the meeting the company's terms were formally accepted by the unions. BL presented a document which was their 'final offer' and which was accepted by the trade union side.

The key clause read as follows. "In accordance with the collective agreement between the company and the trade unions, both parties reaffirm that Audited Plant Status will be established in Cowley Assembly as soon as it is practically possible, and the trade unions and management will cooperate in the productivity improvement measures necessary to qualify for APS which include 39-hour working".

That was interpreted by the Sunday papers in the obvious way. The Sunday Express was the most candid, with its headline: "Car Unions Yield Victory for BL". The first sentence of the lead article read, "An almost total climbdown by union negotiators has paved the way for production to start again this week".

The formula also provides for a four-person committee to inquire into the attitude of management, similar to the committee set up out of the so-called 'swearing' strike last year, which resolved absolutely nothing.

In reality the only way to change the attitude of management is for the unions to win something, in this case to successfully defend the six minutes.

The final clause of the formula says that the unions make no recommendation whatsoever to the mass meeting, and allow the workforce to decide – which is astounding when you consider that the formula was not a compromise, but BL's original terms restated.

BL certainly had it both ways, since they promptly placed advertisements in the newspapers recommending a return to work.

The shop stewards' committee, which had given leadership throughout the strike, was also to be gagged. The major part of the shop stewards' meeting on Monday was taken up with the stewards arguing for the right to make a recommendation to the meeting. When that battle was won, the stewards passed a resolution saying that 'the formula was not a basis for a return to work', although whether, and in what form, this resolution would be put to the mass meeting, was not clear.

The main pressure for the sell out did not in the end come from Terry Duffy. Reports to the stewards' meeting made it clear that Moss Evans was the most determined at national level to bring the strike to an end. He had made the running in both the Carlton Hotel and the Holiday Inn meetings. He apparently fought with Buckle over it, accusing him of being responsible by his support for the continuation of the strike in its early stages.

Formally Moss Evans is presented as being rather to the left in the trade union movement, while Duffy is presented as the extreme right. This demonstrates once more that when the issue of viability arises, and when it is a matter of a major industrial struggle against the government, the left and right of reformism play the same treacherous role.

Failed

The workforce remained completely disciplined after the sell-out at the weekend. Musgrove's call for a return to work on the Monday failed completely. Only one or two workers turned up, to face a picket of several hundred.

At today's mass meeting [Tuesday], the mood was equally strong. The media had for two days set out to create the mentality that the strike was as good as over, and this had obviously had its effect, but it was clear from the reaction of the meeting to the platform that a substantial vote to continue the strike was possible, given a strong lead from the platform.

There was however no such lead. The meeting was gradually talked back to work.

Last night's [Monday] Oxford Mail was very skilfully presented, "The 5000 men and women who have supported the washing-up strike are likely to vote tomorrow for a return to work. But a small minority of militants are claiming that the latest peace terms are a sell-out". It went on to say that the workers would "only be asked to suspend the strike, and not abandon it".

This kind of line was equally skilfully put from the platform this morning by every speaker. Buckle spoke as if the strike was already over. There were endless patronising statements about how magnificent the strike "had been", long references to what "must happen" when everyone was back at work, great praise for the four-person inquiry which was going to bring changes in the plant. Workers were urged to bring their grievances to it so that it could begin its work.

When it came to dealing with the shop stewards' resolution, Buckle simply lied about it. He said the shop stewards had expressed a view, but "we're not recommending either way".

It was of course stressed continually that the platform itself was not recommending either way.

Buckle had been saying that he was not prepared to allow Harold Musgrove to "write his script". But Harold Musgrove, in return for no concessions at all, had certainly determined what was not said at the meeting by Buckle or anyone else.

Bob Fryer, as the final speaker, did mention the stewards' resolution. But it was in the context of a speech which was in tune with the rest of the platform.

Inevitably, after this, the meeting voted to return to work by a majority of about four to one.

It was certainly a major victory for management. The Musgrove management will claim to have cut their teeth and successfully continued Edwardes' hardline management style into the post-Edwardes period in BL. The Tory government will claim it as a victory for their policy on the shop floor, and use it to clamp down in other sectors of industry. Local BL management will use the new commitment they have to APS to force in new manning cuts and push up productivity. Local full-time officials will use it to gain control of a plant traditionally run by a democratically elected shop stewards' movement.

But that's not the whole story.

The strike was the product of a process of breaking down shop floor organisation in the plant, which had gone a long way. The shop stewards' committee, for example, had been reduced to a fraction of its previous strength. But now gains can be made to begin to rebuild the shop stewards' movement.

Hundreds of young workers fresh in the plant have been in action for the first time. They work on tracks where in many cases there are no shop stewards. Militants who came forward in the strike must remain active in the trade union movement, become stewards and trade union activists, begin to tackle the political problems which led another powerful strike to defeat at the hands of the bureaucrats.

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →