Review: The Biodiversity Crisis
Socialist Resistance in print2010sScanned print read by OCR, and not yet proofread: expect run-together words, dropped letters and, where a piece began partway down a page, a few lines of its neighbour. The printed page is the authority.
The Sixth Extinction - an Unnatural History by Elizabeth Kolbert published in 2014 by Bloomsbury at £17.99. Reviewed by Alan Thornett Elizabeth Kolbert is an American journalist and author, a staff writer on the New Yorker, with a strong commitment to the environment. Her new book, The Sixth Extinction - an Unnatural History, is a useful, well written, and accessible work. It is, however, a distressing read for those concerned with the impact of the human population on the ecology of the planet. This is because it sets out in stark terms the crisis of global biodiversity that has developed since the industrial revolution in particular, and how it continues to get worse at an alarming rate today. She argues that from global warming alone (and there are myriad other factors involved), if it reaches its expected maximum by the middle of this century (and it could be worse than that), between 38 and 52 percent of species would be fated to disappear. She argues that an extinction rate on this scale ultimately puts at risk all species on the planet, including, eventually, our own. To put this in perspective she takes looks at 450 million years of geological history and reviews the five previous mass extinctions that are recognised to have taken place since complex animals emerged. (A mass extinction is generally recognised as an event involving a profound loss of biodiversity in a geologically insignificant amount of time.) From this she concludes that we are now witnessing the sixth great extinction. And we are not just witnessing it, she reminds us, we are participants in it, and it's about time we took the issue seriously. She defines the previous mass extinction events as follows The End Ordovician Extinction, 450m years ago, the Late Devonian Extinction, 370m years ago. The End Permian Extinction, which was the most devastating and known as the mother of all extinctions, 225m years ago. The Late Triassic Extinction, 200m years ago, and the most recent, the End Cretaceous Extinction that took place around 60 m years ago that destroyed two thirds of all species at a stroke and saw the end of the dinosaurs. The commonality of these previous extinctions, she argues, is that they were all the result of naturally occurring phenomena ranging from continental drift, glaciation, temperature change, chemical changes such as the acidification of the oceans, volcanic eruptions or earthquakes, or with the End Cretaceous the impact of a giant asteroid. Today's sixth extinction, she contends, is very different. It is as she suggests in the title of the book-an 'unnatural' event. It has the magnitude of a mass extinction but this time it is not brought about by naturally occurring phenomena but as the direct result of the unwitting activity of one individual species on all the rest. This is the most intelligent, successful, and rapacious species the planet has produced-Homo sapiens, or modern human beings. The term she uses for the current geological epoch therefore is the Anthropocene or an epoch defined by the impact of human activity on the ecology of the planet. This was coined by the ecologist Eugene Stormer and supported by the Nobel Prize-winning atmospheric chemist Paul Cruzen, who argues that the impact of human activity on the earth's ecology today is so significant as to constitute a new geological epoch. The term has not yet been officially recognised by the scientific community, though Kolbert is confident that it will be. She argues that since modern humans emerged 200,000 years ago, with their ingenuity, intellect, hunting skills, and drive to explore, they have always had a disproportionate impact on other species. They were responsible for the demise of many of the large mammals that had no other predators but were vulnerable to modern humans. They were also, she argues, responsible for the demise of the Neanderthals, who lacked some of their key attributes. She explains, how, much more recently, as maritime capability developed and colonial expansion started, sailors chomped their way though isolated and vulnerable species such as the dodo, the great auk, the giant tortoise, and flighted birds that had evolved with no fear of predation. The large, but slow moving, Steller's sea cow was hunted to extinction. Such species went from abundance to extinction in very short periods of time. It was not until the industrial revolution, however, and the arrival of capitalism of course (although that is not a factor that she draws attention to), that the full impact of modern humans was felt on the ecology and biodiversity of the planet— with the massive use of fossil fuels in particular. In the course of her research, Kolbert travelled the world to meet the scientists on the front line studying this process and trying to find answers. She visited the rain forest of the Manu National Park in the high Peruvian Andes, one of the planet's biodiversity hot spots, to meet forest ecologist Miles Silman who was studying the effect of global warming by monitoring plants as they migrate up the mountain, at rates of up to 100 feet a year, in search of a higher, cooler, climate zone. The conclusion Silman reaches is that global warming will not just effect biodiversity in the cold regions where the loss of ice, for example, is threatening those species that depend on it such
37 as the polar bears and the ringed seal. It is also affecting, even more severely, the tropical regions where most species live. She travelled to a 10 hectare Amazonia to look at the impact of tropical deforestation and habitat fragmentation on the biodiversity crisis. She found that Reserve 1202 is a part of a patchwork of such reserves, bits of rain forest left behind for 'conservation purposes' after the loggers had cleared the bulk researchers who were studying how the plants and animals deal with such isolation and how much protection such reserves The conclusions she came to were that such fragments provide little protection and that something like 5,000 species are being lost each year-or 14 species a day-in the tropical Amphibian Conservation Centre (EVACC) in Panama, which is dedicated to the survival of endangered amphibians, and linked up with its director Edgardo Griffiths for a scary look at what is happening to the planet's amphibian population. She found that amphibians are not only the group of species that has managed to survive most successfully everything thing that the planet has thrown at them for hundreds of million years but they are now amongst the most endangered group of species-particularly over the past 40 years when their plight has become catastrophic. Amphibians, she points out, are affected not only by habitat loss and general pollution but the spread of diseases and invasive species resulting from the globalisation of travel and the mass transportation of goods, that now reaches every corner of the planet. All this produces a figure that is hard to grasp: that the extinction rate among amphibians could be a mindboggling 45,000 times (yes
* Reviews 38 45,000) higher than the "background" rate—i.e. the rate that existed for millions of years before the current die off began. The background rate of extinction varies with different species of course. With mammals this has been calculated to be about one every 700 years yet in the current event a quarter of all mammal species are at risk over just a few hundred years. She went to Castello Aragonese, a tiny island about thirty kilometres west of Naples, in order meet scientists studying the acidification of the oceans and to see the under-water carbon dioxide vents that render the sea around the island acidic to a degree that is already the fate of some parts of the oceans and could be the fate of the whole ocean if fossil fuels continue to be used at current She describes a scene where calcification for their shells or body structure are in big trouble. Barnacles are bleached white and the shells of the mussels, being dissolved by acid. Small She points out that since the start of the industrial revolution humans have added some 365 billion metric tons of carbon into the atmosphere. Deforestation has added another nine billion tons. Each year this increases by another nine billion tons. This has increased the carbon in the atmosphere to over 400 parts per million and rising. This not only generates the warming of carbon dissolves readily into water it enters the oceans and warming is therefore a double whammy. Today, she observes, the oceans are absorbing around two and a half billion tons of additional carbon a year. The oceans are already 30 times more acidic than they were in 1800 and at the current rate, by the end of the century, they will be 150 times more acidic than at the start of the industrial revolution. Here, she observes, there is a link to the past since ocean acidification played an important part in at least two of the previous two mass extinctions at a time when all life was confined to the oceans. She visited the tiny One Tree Island on the Great Barrier Reef to meet scientists from the University of Queensland who were studying the health of the coral reefs-and to witness the annual coral spawning. She discovered that the threat to coral reefs does not just come from acidification but also from overfishing, which promotes algae growth, deforestation and the resulting loss of water clarity, and dynamite fishing but, most importantly from global warming. Tropical reefs need warm seas but their temperature range is very narrow. Excessive heat disrupts their reproduction process and causes a condition called bleaching. She points out that there have been three major bleaching events in recent years-1998, 2005, and 2010—and that the frequency and intensity of such events is expected to increase as the She looks at the mass die-off of millions of bats in the northeast fungus transported around the imminent extinction of large and iconic species such as Suci the Sumatran rhino in Cincinnati Zoo, a member of a species on the very edge of extinction, who can't ovulate unless she senses there is a male around who is ready to mate. And since the nearest male is 10,000 miles away Suci has a serious reproductive problem. She looks at the problem of introduced and invasive species and concludes (remarkably) that at in any 24 hour period 10,000 moved around the world just in ballast water. She looks at the example of Hawaii where a new invasive species is added every distribution, she concludes that we are moving towards a situation where the world will be just one big continent. There is an abundance of additional examples Elizabeth Kolbert could give to make her case. As I was writing this review there was news that barn owl numbers in Britain have reached a dangerous new low. But she has done more than enough, in my view, to make her case that we are living through the epoch She doesn't offer any quick solutions or urge us to step up our campaigning activities in defence of the environment and of endangered speciesalthough this is implicit in what she says, the people she meets, and how she presents them. The book is an appeal for a greater awareness of what is going on. She urges us to think more deeply about our own role in the process: "If you want to think about why humans are so dangerous to other species, you can have a picture of a poacher in Africa carrying an AK-47 or a logger in the Amazon gripping an picture yourself, holding a book She also poses an important question. In an extinction event of our own making, she asks, what will happen to us? Her answer runs as follows: "having freed ourselves from the constraints of evolution, humans nevertheless remain dependent on the earth's biological and geochemical systems. By disrupting these systems— cutting down tropical rainforests, altering the composition of the atmosphere, acidifying the oceans-we're putting our own survival in danger... When a mass extinction occurs, it takes out the weak, but it also lays low The advantage we have, she argues, is that whilst the humans was for most of the time unwitting it is no longer unwitting. We have the ability to take a new course, should we choose to do so, and its about time we discussed it seriously.
Resistance Books
Revolutionary Activism in the 1950s & 60s Ernest Tate, A Memoir Volume 1, Canada 1955-1965 tographs by Michel Lambett TAX RICH REVOLUTIONARY ACTIVISM IN THE 1950s & 60s A Memoir by Emest Tate Published by Resistance Books Ernest Tate's memoir is an important contribution to the history of the left in Britain and Canada during a unique period. This is the story of a socialist activist during the fifteen-year period from 1955 to 1970 Volume I covers the political engagement of a working-class immigrant to Canada from Northern Ireland, and his involvement in the Socialist Educational League. Volume II documents Ernest Tate's participation in UK radical politics from 1965-1970, including being in the leadership of the International Marxist Group and Vietnam Solidarity Campaign. Price: Vol I - £13 (inc p&p), Vol II - £15 (inc p&p) or £20 (inc p&p) for a combined order of the two volumes. BANCOCRACY Published by Merlin Press and Resistance Books This book facilitates an understanding of several key issues: How and why did this crisis develop? The impact of the deregulation of banks, their manipulations and crimes; The role of the European Central Bank and the US Federal Reserve System; Government complicity. Eric Toussaint looks looks towards the socialisation of banks and for the cancelling of illegitimate public debt. Written in a simple manner, it is an indispensable tool to understand the crisis and to explore coherent altematives.
Revolutionary Activism in the 1950s & 6os Ernest Tate, A Memoir Volume 2, Britain 1965-1970 FORTHCOMING IN 2015 WE THE INDIANS The indigenous peoples of Peru and the struggle for land by Hugo Blanco Published by Merlin Press and Resistance Books Hugo Blanco was a key protagonist in the struggles of the indigenous peoples and struggles for land reform in the 1950s and 1960s These pages, written in bursts, disorderly, jubilant and desperate, tell of the adventures and mistortunes of the man who headed the campesino struggle in Peru, the organiser of the rural trade unions, the man who pushed for an agrarian reform born from below and fought for from below. www.resistancebooks.org Dangerous Liaisons:
The marriages and
divorces of Marxism
and Feminism
CINZIA ARRUZZA
prologue by
Penelope Duggan DANGEROUS LIAISONS: THE MARRIAGES AND DIVORCES OF MARXISM AND FEMINISM by Cinzia Arruza Published by Resistance Books and Merlin Press The first part is historical, the second theoretical. Historical examples show time and again the controversial and often difficult relationship between feminism and Marxism. The theoretical questions discussed include the origins of women's oppression domestic labour and patriarchy. Price £10 (inc p&p) THE FAR RIGHT ACROSS EUROPE Most of the new parties are not traditional fascist organisations. They put forward an idea of defending ordinary people against the corrupt elites and ravages of global capitalism. The racism of the past is being replaced by a rhetoric of the incompatibility of progressive western culture against conservative Islam. The Front National in France is the most well known, but similar organisations exist in across Europe. The book, written by activists and researchers, looks at the development of the far right and the impact across Europe. It will help develop an understanding and strategies to confront this new danger.
Green Capitalism:
why it can't work
DANIEL TANURO
LEFT UNITY SOLIDARITY DEBATE ACTION Join Left Unity T he welfare state is being torn apart by Tory
austerity. The NHS, benefits, the post, the fire service - nothing has been safe from their axe. The Lib Dems have been the Tories' coalition
stooges. And all the main parties have fuelled the rise of
UKIP by trying to pin the blame on migrants.
Labour, who should be standing up against all this, have failed again and again to do so. They have even joined in with attacking the poorest, instead of the real culprits: the rich and the bankers who blew up the economy. That is why the Left Unity party exists. Founded in November 2013, Left Unity already has around 2,000 members and 50 branches across the country. This is a new kind of party, with feminism, socialism, environmentalism and anti-racism at its heart. It's a party that supports the campaigns and struggles of ordinary people, for public services, for equality, and for real deTo join visit mocracy, and it is against all forms of dishttp://leftunity.org crimination.
We say no one should have to choose between heating and eating, no one should have to pay for their healthcare or education - and everyone should have a roof over their head. It's that simple.